Examples of Assessment Nonconformities
Below is a non-exhaustive list of findings that may generally arise after an assessment:
§ 4.1.4: Risks to impartiality have not been identified for all personnel, particularly recent hires.
§ 4.2.5: No provisions are in place regarding the protection of confidentiality within the organization.
§ 5.5.b: Operator backup is not ensured, and no formal provisions have been established to cover the potential absence of the primary operator.
§ 5.7.a: No formal provisions exist regarding the laboratory’s communication process.
§ 6.2.2: Tests are performed by trained personnel who are external to the company, with no clarification of the conditions under which these personnel intervene.
§ 6.2.3: The department manager is authorized to perform certain tests but has not practiced them for five years and cannot provide evidence of maintained competence.
§ 6.2.5: Internal training for new operators is formalized, but no quantitative evidence can be provided: no records, no comparative results, and no defined assessment criteria.
§ 6.2.6.d: Results were sent to the customer by email without being validated by an authorized and approved signatory.
§ 6.3.3: Tests are performed in premises that do not allow the environmental conditions required by the standard to be maintained during the summer.
§ 6.4.5: The equipment is not calibrated over the range in which it is actually used, and the laboratory’s requirement was not formalized in the order placed with the service provider.
§ 6.4.7: Failure to comply with the requirements of an ASTM standard regarding verification intervals, for example ISO: 1 year; ASTM: 6 months.
§ 6.4.8: Technicians cannot easily determine the status of the equipment.
§ 6.4.10: The organization does not perform any intermediate checks on equipment covered by the scope of accreditation.
§ 6.4.13: The software used by the laboratory is not identified or referenced in the documentation.
§ 6.5.1: The laboratory has two pieces of equipment to perform the same test, but neither the reports nor the records indicate which equipment was used.
§ 6.5.2.a: Use of an internal standard that is not traceably calibrated and has no equipment history record, with no evidence of traceability and calibration to SI units.
§ 6.6.1: The external auditor, the ISO/IEC 17025 training organization, etc., are not listed in the approved supplier list.
§ 6.6.1: The laboratory, which had its annual internal audit performed by an external person, cannot provide formal evidence of that person’s competence.
§ 6.6.2.b: The subcontractor evaluation questionnaire is either unavailable or has never been completed.
§ 6.6.2.c: Certificates issued by external service providers contain reference errors and/or refer to outdated versions of standards.
§ 7.1.5: The laboratory does not inform the customer that certain tests will be subcontracted externally.
§ 7.2.1.2: Technical personnel do not have access to the documentation associated with their daily tasks.
§ 7.2.1.3: Failure to comply with the test method described in the standard, due to the absence of formalized provisions in the corresponding work instruction.
§ 7.2.1.5: The laboratory does not ensure that an important requirement of the test standard, which may have a direct impact on the results, is verified.
§ 7.6.1: The measurement uncertainty estimation instruction contains inconsistencies: coverage factor systematically set at k=2, no verification of degrees of freedom using the Welch-Satterthwaite formula, failure to consider certain influencing factors, standard uncertainty used as expanded uncertainty, and underestimated uncertainty.
§ 7.6.1: The laboratory provides the measurement uncertainties mentioned as examples in the test standards.
§ 7.6.2: The laboratory performs its own calibrations but does not estimate the associated uncertainties.
§ 7.7.1.d: The form used to record the customer’s request does not take into account the customer’s preference regarding the use of a specific test method.
§ 7.7.2: No participation in an interlaboratory comparison campaign for tests included in the scope of accreditation, where such campaigns exist.
§ 7.7.3: The organization carries out interlaboratory comparisons itself with external accredited laboratories, but no analysis of the results is performed, and the material used has no reliable data: grade and target value unknown.
§ 7.8.2.2: Reports systematically contain transcription errors, such as incorrect values, inconsistent dates, or incorrect customer references.
§ 7.8.6.1: The laboratory includes a statement of conformity with a specification without documenting the decision rule.
§ 7.8.8.3: No information is provided to the customer regarding the changes made to a replaced report.
§ 7.9.1: No customer complaints have been recorded in recent years!!!!
§ 7.10.1.b: Actual nonconformities were classified as opportunities for improvement during an internal audit, and no action was taken.
§ 7.11.2: The Excel spreadsheets used for uncertainty calculations are not referenced in the documentation and are not protected.
§ 7.11.6: The Excel spreadsheets used for uncertainty calculations have not been validated.
§ 8.3.2.b: The documentation is not up to date, with references to obsolete or deleted documents, or to documents whose coding has changed.
§ 8.4.2: The filing method and retention period are not specified in the documentation.
§ 8.8.2: The laboratory’s internal audits are performed without defined frequencies.
The organization’s website refers to the logo of the notified body but does not include its accreditation number.
The laboratory, during an initial assessment, does not have a draft report template showing the type of report it will issue once accredited.
Percentage distribution of the 1,462 nonconformities by requirement
